Ham To Ham #23 - August 1997
73's Ham To Ham column
c/o Dave Miller, NZ9E
7462 Lawler Avenue
Niles, IL 60714-3108
USA
E-mail: dmiller14@juno.com
You're invited to send me your tips, suggestions, ideas and shortcuts, as always, to the
addresses shown above. I'm always in the market for new and interesting contributions like this
first item from Ken Guge K9KPM. Aside from being an interesting story in and of itself, it
illustrates how Ken used logical troubleshooting techniques to solve a seemingly illogical
problem.
The mysterious capacitor
"I recently encountered what a first seemed a strange problem with my broad-band VHF/UHF
discone antenna. One of the beauties of the discone design is its very wide-band frequency
capabilities; this one (a commercially made unit) is specified as usable on transmit from 2
meters, on up through the 23 centimeter ham bandÖand an even grater range of potential
usability as a receive-only antenna.
Over the winter, however, my discone's SWR rose dramatically (to over 3:1 at 2-Meters). It
reached the point where the antenna became virtually unusable for either receiving or
transmitting. I first checked the indoor end of the feedline with an ohmmeter, and found that
there was some measurable shunt resistance; this in an antenna that should have displayed a
completely open circuit to DC. Going a little further, I also found that it was acting very much like
a fairly high value capacitor ... about 3,000pfd. in fact! At 2-Meters, that 3,000pfd. (.003ufd.)
would be enough to effectively by-pass all but the strongest of 2-Meter signals to ground,
working out to about an ohm of capacitive reactance at 144MHz.
My first thought was that perhaps water had somehow worked its way into the coaxial (RG-8X)
cable feeding the antenna, but disconnecting the coax at the far end, and repeating the
measurements, proved conclusively that the coax itself was perfectly all right ... the problem had
to be in the antenna. But what could go wrong with a nicely-machined, well-sealed antenna's
main connection block? There was virtually no open gap for water to enter the connecting block
from the sides nor from above, but yet disassembling the entire machined piece, showed a
considerable amount of internal corrosion and even a small amount of liquid water itself. Figure
1 shows a side view of the basic construction of the antenna Ö not particularly complicated nor
subject to this type of problem. What might possibly have caused this seemingly inexplicable
condition to develop? The antenna's coaxial connector is facing downward, it was unlikely that
water might have worked its way in via this route. Ditto for the rest of the discone's construction.
There just wasn't any obvious way for moisture to enter in a liquid form ... only via humidity in the
air. Here's what I feel happened.
The interior or the connection block has a small, hollow cavity, which though not penetrable by
rain, is subjected to infiltration by moist, humid air (not being hermetically sealed). We have our
fair share of moist, humid days in the Chicago area, often followed by quickly changing
temperatures that can drop amazingly rapidly (sometimes 60 or 70 degrees in just a few hours).
If moist air gets into the connector block's cavity, and then is subjected to a dramatic cool-down,
the moisture in the trapped air will condense out in the form of liquid water. Several episodes of
such a natural occurrence can cause a significant buildup of water inside of a tight (but not
perfectly air-tight) container. I feel that the discone's connecting block cavity was such a
container. Over time, of course, the water worked on the surrounding metal pieces, causing
severe corrosion and changing the pure water into something more like an electrolyte. That
electrolyte, and the otherwise insulated metal pieces inside the block, resulted in a .003ufd.
electrolytic capacitor being developed right inside of my VHF/UHF antenna! Isn't nature
wonderful!
Now here's the moral. If you live in a climate such as that found near Chicago, it might be best
to consider either sealing relatively air-tight connections entirely, or if that's not practical, then
leaving enough free-air circulation space so that air exchange can take place more rapidly when
climatic conditions shift quickly. In that way, humid air has a chance to be flushed out before it
can condense and deposit it's water into the open cavity. In the case of my discone antenna, I
chose to fill that open cavity above the bottom connector with Stuf (reg. trade mark). That's what
it's called ... Stuf. It's a Teflon (reg. trade mark)-based grease that's compatible with electrical
connections, and is made by Cross Devices of Cutchogue, NY. It's described as a dielectric
waterproofing filler for coax connectors. I bought my tube of Stuf from AES in Milwaukee, but it's
probably available elsewhere as well. I packed the grease into the cavity of the connection block
so that some of it actually oozed out when everything was reassembled and a new connector
was installed, assuring me that the cavity would now be virtually air-tight (at least tight enough to
prevent a similar occurrence in the future). We'll see.
After reassembly, the antenna showed perfect continuity through the connection points and no
shunt impedance whatsoever, so I'm reasonably confident that the job will hold. I hope that my
experience may have some value to other Ham To Ham readers who've encountered similar
problems with outdoor connections. Remember to stick with it, there's an explanation for
everything!"
Moderator's note: Thanks for letting us in on that experience, Ken. In the future, I for one, will
view my outdoor antenna connections very differently! Ken is absolutely right when you stop to
think about it. Any enclosure that's capable of trapping moist, humid air is a potential water
reservoir, just waiting to happen, when a quick change in temperature takes place. Filling that
reservoir with an RF compatible grease (such as he did), is probably the best insurance against
an event like K9KPM experienced. Good tip Ken!
Circular memory
Here's a clever, easy-to-implement tip from Frank Brumbaugh W4LJD that won't void a single
manufacturer's warranty: "If you ever have difficulty remembering what band your antenna tuner
might actually be tuned to, then here's the gadget for you! It's never a good idea to key your
transceiver into an unknown load, as can easily happen if you've forgotten what band (or band
segment) you last used your tuner (antenna transmission line matching network) on. Many
tuners are not marked with regard to actual band or frequency range, so it's often difficult to see
where the tuner is set just by glancing at it...but no more!
Take a look at Figure 2 and make up something similar for yourself, either out of cardboard or
artist's drawing board. What's shown in Figure 2 is somewhat reminiscent of the old circular
slide rules used by engineering students before the advent of electronic calculators and now
palmtop computers. It's just a circular cardboard cutout that mounts onto another piece of
square or rectangularly shaped cardboard, with a single screw through its center and a nut
placed on from behind. All of your normal ham band haunts can be shown around the perimeter
of the movable circle, and when you've tuned everything up correctly, move the cardboard circle
to the proper position to indicate what band or band-segment you're tuned to. That's it, nothing
elaborate, just an always-close-at-hand reminder for those of us who need it...don't laugh, if you
don't need it now, you will!"
Reach for the stars
Here's a tip from Thomas Hart AD1B for making it easier to operate through the RS-12 satellite:
"Since becoming 'seriously' involved in hamming through the RS-12 satellite, I've been seeking
out ways to make the experience even more fun. Using the satellite involves transmitting on the
low end of the 15-meter phone band and listening on the satellite portion of the 10-meter band.
Using only a Kenwood TS-430S, I've been able to put the transceiver's built-in split-VFO to work
as the means of generating the 15-meter up/10-meter down frequency offset needed. As time
went on, I thought that it might be interesting to hear my downlink signal in real-time too, so I
tried using another 10-meter-only transceiver that I owned for that purpose. The results were
disappointing, perhaps partly due to the transceiver itself not being sensitive enough, perhaps
partly due to desensing caused by my own 15-meter transmit signal. I heard myself on the
downlink, but it wasn't nearly what I had hoped for in terms of signal strength and reliability.
My next step was to try listening for myself on RS-12's 2-meter downlink instead. I purchased a
reasonably priced 2-meter to 10-meter converter from Hamtronics (Tel: 1-716-392-9430), used
the 10-meter-only transceiver as the tunable IF for the converter, and ended up very satisfied
with the overall results. The use of a sensitive receiving converter ahead of a mediocre 10-meter
transceiver seems to be an economical answer for a better downlink monitor. Since the noise
level and sensitivity are determined in the 2-meter converter, even a converted CB SSB
transceiver may work well enough as the IF, demodulator and audio stages of a setup like this.
Why not give it a try if you happen to be strapped for cash, but would still like a few bells and
whistles in your satellite station?"
Cable shrinker
Here's another good mobiling suggestion from Phil Salas AD5X: "In my mobile VHF ham
installation, I like to use RG-8X (or RG-8M from Radio Shack (reg trade mark)) to bring the RF
from radio at the dashboard, out to the hatchback antenna mount in the rear. To then exit the
vehicle, I've rigged up a short (1 foot) section of RG-174/U to get through the car's hatchback
gasket, and then to the outside antenna mount.
RG-174/U 50 ohm coax is the perfect size to use...being just a tenth of an inch in diameter...it
easily feeds through my car's hatchback weather-stripping without spoiling the purpose behind
the weather-stripping gasket. Splicing the RG-8X to the RG-174U takes place via a pair of BNC
connectors and a BNC feed-thru barrel. Rigging a BNC connector for the RG-174/U can be a bit
tricky, but I've had good results using a crimp-on type of BNC plug (intended for RG-58 coax) but
soldering it instead to the miniature RG-174/U coax.
Here's how I've done it: First, I tin the lip of the BNC's collar, then strip off about 1/2" of the RG-
174/U's outer black jacket. I unbraid the exposed shield and fold it back along the remaining
jacket. Next, I'll strip off all but 1/8" of the center conductor's insulation, cut the center conductor
to 1/4" length, tin it, and slip the BNC center pin over the tinned end, carefully soldering it in
place with minimum heat and very little additional solder. If too much solder is used, the center
conductor pin may not fit back into the BNC's shell properly. If done correctly, you should now
be able to insert the RG-174 finished cable and pin into the BNC's shell far enough so that the
center pin is seated firmly and the tip protruding just shy of the end of the BNC shell. The final
step is to solder the RG-174/U's braid to the previously tinned collar of the BNC plug assembly,
again using the absolute minimum amount of heat to do the job. Allow plenty of cooling time and
don't move the assembly during the cool-down period...these tiny cables can't withstand much
heat, so it's best to practice on a scrap piece first.
Last, but not least, I put a short length of heat shrink tubing over the BNC's collar and part
of the cable, and shrink it in place. The addition of the shrink tubing gives a protective,
professional looking touch to the job. Finally, connect the open end of the RG-174/U to the
antenna mount that you're using, again finishing up with a short piece of heat-shrink tubing for
stress resistance and weather tightness. The entire cable assembly should hold up well if
reasonable care is taken to make sure that it doesn't get "pinched" at any time in the hatchback-
door to frame interface. It's also one that you'll be proud to show off to your ham buddies."
Battery tap tip
This idea is from Jerry Lagersbrom AA0MO: "Here's a tip to keep in mind if you need to make a
high current connection directly to your automobile's 12 volt battery, such as for that new mobile
ham rig you just bought. Instead of splicing into the existing battery connections at or near the
battery's terminals, simply use the "spare" set of terminals that already exist on many of the
current line of auto batteries. Since some automobile makers use the side-mounted terminals for
their main connections, and some use the top terminal scheme, battery makers will often provide
two sets of terminals on new and replacement batteries. It helps to keep down the needed
inventory that dealers have to keep on hand. It also makes it very easy for the ham radio mobile
operator who wants to tap into the battery right at the source itself...which is the recommended
way of doing the job. Simply purchase the correct terminal kit (either top or side) opposite from
what you car's manufacturer has chosen, and use those terminals for your mobile rig. When it
comes time to sell the car, it's an easy matter to remove the radio's cabling, since you didn't have
to splice into the original factory wiring for your installation. It also makes it easy to disconnect
your added wiring should it become necessary to isolate a future power drain problem...at least
you can easily exonerate your ham gear from the formula."
Murphy's Corollary: Any rechargeable tool battery will run-down just moments before the
last of the important tasks is completed.
Many thanks to the contributors who make this column worthwhile each month, without their
continued input, I'd run-down pretty quickly. They include:
Ken Guge K9KPM
1107 E. Woodrow Avenue
Lombard, IL 60148-3127
e-mail: k9kpm@juno.com
J. Frank Brumbbaugh W4LJB
P.O. Box 30
c/o Defendini
Salinas, PR 00751
Thomas Hart AD1B
54 Hermaine Avenue
Dedham, MA 02026
Phil Salas AD5X
1517 Creekside Drive
Richardson, TX 75081
Jerry Lagersbrom AA0MO
1301 1st. Avenue
Plattsmouth, NE 68048
Be sure to check out the Ham To Ham column's home page on the world wide web at:
http://www.rrsta.com/hth.
Note: The ideas and suggestions contributed to this column by its readers have not necessarily
been tested by the column's moderator nor by the staff of 73 Magazine, and thus no guarantee of
operational success is implied. Always use your own best judgment before modifying any
electronic item from the original equipment manufacturer's specifications. No responsibility is
implied by the moderator or 73 Magazine for any equipment damage or malfunction
resulting from information supplied in this column.
Please send all correspondence relating to this column to 73 Magazine's Ham To Ham column,
c/o Dave Miller, NZ9E, 7462 Lawler Avenue, Niles, IL 60714-3108, USA. All contributions used
in this column will be reimbursed by a contributor's fee of $10, which includes its exclusive use
by 73 Magazine. We will attempt to respond to all legitimate contributor's ideas in a timely
manner, but be sure to send all specific questions on any particular tip to the originator of
the idea, not to this column's moderator nor to 73 Magazine.
Note: If you would like a copy of any of the circuit diagrams or figures referred to in
this column, simply send a SASE to Ham To Ham Column, c/o Dave Miller NZ9E,
7462 Lawler Avenue, Niles, IL 60714-3108 and indicate the month and circuit or
figure name on your request. No requests will be honored without a self-addressed and
adaquately stamped envelope (SASE).